Minnesotans For Sustainability©

 

Home ] Up ] Feedback Please ] Table of Contents ] Search MFS ] MFS News ]

Sustainable Society:  A society that balances the environment, other life forms, and human interactions over an indefinite time period.

 

 

 

 

 


 

 

The Fine Print of the Senate Betrayal

What’s In the Comprehensive Approach” To Illegal Immigration

  An analysis of the Specter-Hagel S-2611 Immigration Bill
Marcus Epstein
*
May 2006

 


All these facts, except those with an *asterisk* are in the text of the legislation. Because it is long and cumbersome to read, we included links to articles and studies that summarize the legislation. If you have the time and patience to read the bill, see at <http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/z?c109:S.2611:>. The Federation for American Immigration Reform has summarized the Amendments and the Bill in slightly less technical jargon. See at < http://www.fairus.org/site/PageServer?pagename=amnesty_senate_debate > for Amendments, and for the main text see at < http://www.fairus.org/site/DocServer/may3sidebyside.pdf?docID=941 > (this text is a PDF chart comparing several competing bills, the Senate just passed the one labeled Specter-Hagel)
.

Amnesty

  • Amnesty for 85% of the nation’s estimated 12 million illegal aliens (10.2 million) 60% of illegals will be able to receive Amnesty immediately, while 15 percent must go to a foreign port of entry to apply for citizenship (Source: Heritage Foundation).
  • The remaining 15 percent ( 1.8 million) illegal aliens are expected to return home, but there is absolutely nothing in the bill that would facilitate that action! (Source: Heritage Foundation).
  • Employers who hire illegal aliens will also receive Amnesty (Source: The Arizona Republic).

Privileges for Illegals and Costs to Taxpayers

  • Illegal Aliens will be eligible for Social Security! (Source: Washington Times).
  • Illegal Aliens students will qualify for in State Tuition, a benefit not given to out of state American citizens! (Source: Asian Journal).
  • The increased welfare payments that illegals will receive once they receive Amnesty will cost American taxpayers 30 million dollars a year —The biggest welfare increase in 35 years! (Source: The Heritage Foundation).*

Guestworkers

  • An increase of 66 million legal immigrants on top of our current immigration quotas because of the guestworker program! (Source: Heritage Foundation).*
  • Guestworkers cannot “"terminated from employment by any employer . . . except for just cause." A right not given to American Citizens! (Source: Robert Novak).
  • Guestworkers also must be paid the prevailing wage, another right not given to American citizens! (Source: Robert Novak).
  • 1.5 million agricultural workers may also apply for guestworker status! (Source: Federation for American Immigration Reform).
  • The so called “temporary” guestworkers are allowed to apply for permanent residency (Source: Federation for American Immigration Reform).

Other Atrocities

  • Increases the visa caps for all countries (Source: Federation for American Immigration Reform).
  •  
  • An Amendment Proposed by Rick Santorum would greatly increase the number of countries whose citizens can enter the U.S. without a visa. (Source: Federation for American Immigration Reform).
  •  
  • Increases employment based green cards from 140,000 to 450,000 a year for the next 10 years! The number will then go down to 290,000 a year afterward. (Source: Federation for American Immigration Reform).

Doublespeak in the Bill

  • Bill states that guestworkers cannot take the jobs of American workers, but the definition of "United States Worker" includes temporary foreign guest workers, so the protection is meaningless. (Source: Robert Novak).
  • The law establishes English as the official language, but then makes it illegal to “punish” someone for not speaking English!
  • The law says if someone has been convicted of a felony or three misdemeanors they will not be eligible for Amnesty and are supposed to be deported. However, it makes an exception for “hardship cases” and any. Also, anyone who claims they were not aware of their deportation order can appeal. (Source: Heritage Foundation).

What the bill does not include:

  • There is nothing in the bill that would require the 15% of illegal aliens who are not eligible for Amnesty to go home. Nor is there anything that would punish any of the illegal aliens for not doing what they are supposed to do. (Source: Heritage Foundation).
  •  
  • An Amendment requiring voters to show valid government issued identification when voting in federal elections was defeated. (Source: Associated Press).
  • The Isakson Amendment stating that the Secretary of Homeland Security had to certify that the borders are secure before and border of the Amnesty or Guestworker provisions were enacted was defeated (Source: Federation for American Immigration Reform).

* Note: These studies were done by the Heritage Foundation and are not in the text of the bill, but are based on their own estimates. While they are not the final word, other researchers have confirmed their findings, and they have not been widely challenged.

Marcus Epstein is Director of Research for Team America PAC.
______
* Courtesy of Team America PAC
Information references are given at the original.
See original at < http://teamamericapac.org/index.php?p=63 >.

Home
Up
 

Please send mail to webmaster@mnforsustain.org with questions or comments about this web site. Minnesotans For Sustainability (MFS) is not affiliated with any government body, private, or corporate entity. Copyright © 2002, 2003, 2004 Minnesotans For Sustainability